50 methods to make media pay: Paywalls | What’s New in Publishing


That is an excerpt from our free-to-download report, 50 Methods To Make Media Pay

On-line paywalls are a main means for publishers to encourage audiences to take out digital subscriptions. Upon hitting the paywall, readers will discover themselves unable to entry additional content material except both they change into subscribers, or look forward to an prolonged time period for the paywall to reset. 

The previous 12-18 months noticed quite a few publishers navigating a paywall tightrope; balancing the necessity to supply doubtlessly life-saving public well being info with the necessity to develop reader revenues, particularly within the face of a dramatic promoting downturn. 

Many information retailers have traditionally dropped paywalls (or parts of them) for emergencies, breaking information tales or main occasions. Consistent with this, a number of publishers did the identical factor with COVID-related content material, together with retailers with traditionally agency paywalls, just like the Monetary Occasions. It wasn’t a transfer that everybody agreed with, and because the disaster continued, some publishers – like McClatchy within the U.S. – determined to reinstate their full paywalls

Picture through the Monetary Occasions

On the similar time, as the latest Digital Information Report notes, “the final yr has additionally seen extra high quality journalism go behind paywalls… El País in Spain, El Tiempo in Colombia, and Information 24 in South Africa are amongst these to have began their paywall journeys within the midst of the pandemic.”

Alongside this, we’ve persistently seen retailers lowering the quantity of non-paywalled content material audiences can entry. In late 2017, the New York Occasions determined to scale back the variety of free articles out there to “most” non-subscribers every month from 10 to 5. Previous to that, in 2012, it reduce the variety of month-to-month free articles from 20 to 10. Leap forward to 2021, and the Grey Girl is transferring a quantity (18) of their newsletters behind their paywall.  

We will anticipate different publishers to observe go well with – as paywalls are tightened and extra content material more and more turns into subscriber-only.

Picture: E-mail to the creator, August 2021

Right here’s a rundown of the most typical forms of paywalls:

1. Laborious paywalls

As seen on the Monetary Occasions or Wall Road Journal, these websites usually preserve all of their content material behind a paywall, that means you need to be a subscriber to entry it.

That mentioned, Chartbeat observes how “onerous paywalls are actually uncommon to search out.” One purpose for that is that “success with a tough paywall could also be an uphill climb, as nearly all of potential subscribers are inclined to bounce offsite when encountering an rigid gate.”

The Occasions (of London) misplaced 90% of its on-line readership when it launched such a paywall a decade in the past, suggesting publishers deploying sort of paywall must be in it for the lengthy haul. 

Extra conventionally, publishers deploying one of these paywall are inclined to concentrate on a selected area of interest. “Are you able to guess what The Economist, The Wall Road Journal, and Monetary Occasions have in widespread?” Chartbeat asks. 

2. Metered paywalls

The sort of paywall permits audiences to devour a specific amount of free content material earlier than they need to subscribe. In recent times, a number of publishers have decreased the quantity of fabric out there to readers earlier than they hit a content material cap. 

Proof suggests there’s a good purpose for this. A 2019 white paper from Harvard’s Shorenstein Middle and the Lenfest Institute concluded “most publishers are too beneficiant” and argued that “cease charges” ought to be decrease if organisations wish to maximise efforts to transform readers into paying subscribers. 

Their analysis discovered that “a majority of publishers with metered fashions set their meter limits at 5 articles monthly or decrease.”  Examples of websites who’ve adopted this method embrace Slate, Medium and Bloomberg. 

Picture:  Meter limits (2018) and the traits over time, based mostly on 500 information organizations with digital subscription or membership fashions between 2011 and 2018, through the Shorenstein Middle and Lenfest Institute

3. Hybrid (aka “Freemium”) paywalls

The beginning of the COVID disaster noticed many publishers adopting this mannequin, with coronavirus content material usually free and outdoors of the paywall, whereas different sections sat behind metered (or onerous) paywalls. 

Nonetheless, some retailers are electing to take this blended method throughout a variety of verticals. USA Immediately determined in July 2021 to maneuver premium content material – corresponding to unique investigations, visible explainers, “thought-provoking takes on the information” and immersive storytelling – behind a paywall, with different content material persevering with to be freely out there. 

“It is a large change,” they wrote, “our digital information has at all times been free. However USA TODAY was based on boldness. Your subscription is an funding in high quality journalism that’s value paying for, journalism that strengthens our communities and our nation.”

A 2019 factsheet from the Reuters Institute recognized the prevalence of this mannequin in Europe, with Le Monde (France), BILD (Germany), and the Impartial (UK) being simply a few of the retailers adopting this method at the moment. 

4. Part particular paywalls

These efforts enable customers to entry standalone verticals. Alongside providing a digital subscription enabling entry to the entire web site, the Telegraph (UK) additionally presents separate packages for sports activities and puzzles

Picture: Prices for the Telegraph’s sports-only subscription bundle (accessed 22 August 2021), through The Telegraph

The New York Occasions is one other newspaper that has efficiently harnessed this method throughout some non-news merchandise. For instance, NYT Cooking prices $5.00 each 4 weeks, or $40 a yr. Individually, for a similar value, in addition they supply a “video games subscription” which incorporates The Occasions’ Crossword (a product that was offered as a standalone subscription). 

5. Gated paywalls 

Not each paywall requires a paid subscription to entry content material. 

Various suppliers have experimented with different techniques, whereby customers have to undertake a particular motion – corresponding to whitelisting the location or turning off advert blockers, taking a brief survey (e.g. Google Client Surveys ), making a consumer account or offering their e mail tackle – in the event that they wish to open the gate to entry sure content material.

These strikes are pushed by the worth of capturing key client knowledge, corresponding to e mail addresses and matters that customers are fascinated about, insights that may then be used to focus on shoppers accordingly. 

Retailers pursuing this method at current embrace The New Yorker and Wired.

Picture: Instance of a pop-up field from Wired, requesting extra info earlier than the reader can devour this story at no cost.

6. Geo-location paywalls

This mannequin means you hit the paywall at completely different factors relying in your IP-address. 

One advantage of this method, as utilized by some newspapers, is that this paywall mannequin can allow native audiences – a extra interesting group for native advertisers – to entry extra content material at no cost. In distinction, these exterior a given IP-range, hit the paywall sooner.

For different media, such because the BBC’s catch-up TV service, iPlayer, whole merchandise are solely out there to customers with particular IP addresses (on this case, contained in the UK). 

You may additionally discover that sure forms of content material (e.g. sport or music) are restricted, relying in your geographic location, usually attributable to rights causes. This consists of quite a few U.S. originated titles, which aren’t GDPR ( a regulation in EU legislation on knowledge safety and privateness within the European Union and the European Financial Space) compliant.

Picture: Screenshots from the creator’s cellphone whereas trying to entry the web site for USA Immediately and The Washington Publish from Europe, July 2021

7. Dynamic paywalls

Has AI introduced an finish to the metered paywall?” requested Piano CEO Trevor Kaufman in 2019. Kaufman’s query was prompted by efforts that allow publishers to set completely different paywalls relying on “an enormous host of variables, whether or not that be geography, content material consumption, go to behaviour, subject material, system, or a wide selection of different metrics.”

Put one other manner, completely different customers will encounter paywalls at completely different occasions, based mostly on a variety of various metrics, which can embrace the kind of content material you’ve landed on, your location, system sort and shopping historical past. These indicators are getting used to foretell a customers’ probability of subscribing.  New York Media and Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ, Switzerland) are a few of the retailers which have used this paywall mannequin. 

“Immediately often is the loss of life of the meter,” Kaufamn wrote, explaining how this method works, “however it’s the start of a brand new age of smarter, extra satisfying automation.”

8. Multi-dimensional paywalls

All of those completely different approaches could be mixed to incorporate parts of those fashions. 

For instance, a hybrid-dynamic paywall – as used by SME (Dennik SME) in Slovakia – might preserve some content material behind a paywall, whereas on the similar time additionally locking audiences out as soon as they hit a specific amount of free content material. 

Picture: illustration of a hybrid-dynamic paywall, through Deep.BI

The rationale for this blended method, because the platform supplier Admiral explains, relies on a realisation that “guests should not homogenous, even for a extremely area of interest content material web site.” 

“Some are okay with viewing adverts, however need extra management over the sort and frequency. Others are comfortable to share a social login in trade for an ad-lite expertise.”  

Put merely, “nearly all of guests merely aren’t able to “get married” with a paid digital subscription in a writer’s first ask,” Admiral notes. “As an alternative, multi-dimensional metering helps publishers and guests get to know one another, change into pals, and date within the courtship main as much as subscription.”

Initially printed in What’s New in Publishing in January 2022. Whereas a few of the knowledge factors might have advanced, the evaluation and conclusion stay extremely related.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here